Relationship between human trafficking and prostitution

Most human trafficking related to prostitution - Washington Times

relationship between human trafficking and prostitution

Coordination of the Fight against Trafficking of Human Beings National Anti- Trafficking Coordinator Human Trafficking Trafficking for Prostitution and Sexual. Day and night, he orchestrated her every move. She was told when to sit, stand, come and go. She was also told whom she would provide. Sex trafficking and prostitution have negative, legal and practical and maintaining inequality between men and women, north and south.

We also looked in more detail at Sweden, Germany and Denmark, which changed their prostitution laws during the past 13 years.

There was a problem providing the content you requested

Sweden prohibited it inwhile Germany further legalised it by allowing third-party involvement in Denmark decriminalised it in so that self-employed prostitution is legal, but brothel operation is still forbidden.

Germany showed a sharp increase in reports of human trafficking upon fully legalising prostitution in The number of human trafficking victims in in Denmark, where it is decriminalised, was more than four times that of Sweden, where it is illegal, although the population size of Sweden is about 40 per cent larger.

That legalised prostitution increases human trafficking inflows is likely, but cannot be proven with available evidence. Other reasons might speak against prohibiting prostitution despite its impact on human trafficking, however. Working conditions could be substantially improved for prostitutes—at least those legally employed—if prostitution is legalised.

Although he emphasizes that these are separate issues, he argues that the fact that consent is considered irrelevant in situations where vulnerability is exploited may, in practice, come close to criminalising prostitution in general, the reverse being equally possible.

relationship between human trafficking and prostitution

However, we also encountered cases, either reported by interviewees or through analyses of legal proceedings, in which women did not know that the work awaiting them in Portugal was prostitution. Extreme cases of deception — in which the woman did not know she would be forced to work as a prostitute or in any other activity of a sexual nature — involve primarily women of other nationalities, in particular those from Central and Eastern Europe, Asia and Africa.

This perception merits various considerations. Firstly, it should be noted that it was through violent cases involving women from Eastern Europe that Portugal woke up to the reality of this kind of trafficking.

Indeed, in these informal groups it is not unusual for the recruiters to be people who have great credibility in the eyes of their victims, since they are friends, family members, colleagues, etc. As a member of the criminal police force told us: That is not to say that she might not be, that issues concerning her origins before coming here might not make her a victim of trafficking.

But the tendency is not to consider this. This is a situation that clearly has to be corrected. On the other hand, what happens with this Moldavian and others from Eastern Europe is that we immediately look at them differently, because these are situations that clearly represent potential cases of trafficking.

Not just pimping, not just illegal immigration, but potential trafficking situations. Following on from the work of Kelly and Regan apud Aronowitz, The first level is associated with total coercion, when victims are kidnapped and there is no consent whatsoever. The third level involves a lesser degree of deception, when women know they will be working in the sex industry, but not in prostitution.

Finally, the fourth level of victimisation, which is taken to be the least serious, concerns women who, prior to departure, already knew that they would be working as prostitutes, but did not know the extent to which they would be controlled, intimidated, indebted and exploited.

There are many reasons why these cases run the risk of going unnoticed: A third aspect concerns the fact that illegal immigration is a situation in which both promoters and victims the immigrants and the exploited share a fear of the state and the security forces. Finally, there is the fact that, due to its illegal nature, prostitution combined with pimping almost always operates in a climate of fear even when trafficking is not involved that is well justified by the very real likelihood of violent reprisals.

But it also refers to the tacit climate of reprisals and violence which pervade the world of pimping, deterring any kind of denunciation of cases of sexual exploitation, not only by the women involved in trafficking situations but also by other women and other actors who are aware of, or strongly suspect, these facts.

Final reflections 58In recent years, due to great international pressure in this area, various governments have sought to develop strategies to combat the trafficking of people in general and women in particular. The main strategy on the part of governments has been to create and reinforce appropriate legislation.

This is, no doubt, fundamental, since despite the intensive production of conventions and international declarations, concern for the gravity of the trafficking of women for the purposes of sexual exploitation is still not reflected in the penal legislation of various countries. Furthermore, there are certain aspects referred to in the letter of the law and in its application which merit our concern, in the light of what we said above.

Firstly, legislation tends to be specifically directed towards the criminal pursuit of trafficking without taking into account other fundamental legislation, such as the reinforcement of immigrant or labour rights, whether for national or other citizens. In this scenario, the risk of focusing on criminalising traffickers and neglecting the human rights of the people caught up in trafficking is high.

For various authors, the laws which lead to trafficked women being immediately deported, or which make their stay in the host country dependent on giving evidence, are a particular concern. For some, the attention paid by governments to trafficking, in particular in Western Europe and North America, has focused more on issues of migration and control of migratory flows than on human rights, as the more restrictive immigration laws show.

Some NGOs and academics believe that these measures ultimately become more a part of the problem than a solution: The latter is directed towards the fact that the universality attributed to the declaration of human rights is nothing more than a Western perspective on the subject, whilst the South still does not to have a clear voice on its own problems, and that specific aspects of common problems are not taken into consideration e.

Santos, ; Kapur, From the outset, when speaking of the human rights of trafficked women it is necessary to understand that these women differ and come from culturally and socially diverse regions — in other words, attention needs to be paid to cultural differences, avoiding universalist readings.

relationship between human trafficking and prostitution

Whilst it is fundamental that gender should not be forgotten in the issue of sex trafficking, it is necessary not to resort to an essentialism which views women as a homogenous category, not the least because when causes are homogenised, the same can easily happen to solutions. Perhaps for this reason, despite the multiple responses of the United Nations and various governments to the problem of violence against women in the past decade, rape, enforced prostitution and trafficking still persist and are spreading.

Sexual slavery and the forms of extreme exploitation to which female prostitutes may be subjected undoubtedly represent situations of suffering. Yet even voluntary consent merits analysis. The wretchedness and poverty underlying such decisions should be confronted.

Most human trafficking related to prostitution

Voluntary acts usually occur on an individual level, but are the expression of collective acts of social injustice. Society creates situations in which a young man or woman has no other chance of earning a wage for themselves or their family except through prostitution. This puts society as a whole under debate, namely a capitalist society which creates these forms of constraint within which voluntary acts are possible, and also leads us to reflect on the entire ethical and moral context within which this issue is debated.

This discussion should not be limited to the causes of trafficking, but also to the solutions.

There is a complex relationship between legalised prostitution and human trafficking. | EUROPP

Because of the strong social stigma attached to female prostitutes, their civil and human rights are frequently violated Anderson and Davidson, Only in a few countries are women who work as prostitutes effectively protected by the law and, as we have seen in the case of Portugal, the stereotypes and preconceptions relating to prostitution and immigrant women of particular nationalities may mean that the law is not enforced. Effective help for women who are the victims of trafficking implies fighting our own preconceptions and stereotypes.

It presupposes the definition of an aid policy that does not exert any control over the choices these women make and respects their human rights in different cultural contexts, without involving a universalist discourse that prevents us from understanding the political, social and cultural relations underlying their choices once they arrive in the country of their destination.

In our view, a progressive attitude in this area can only be an attitude which strengthens collective awareness of these women and enables them to escape the subhuman conditions in which they find themselves, by constructing their citizenship.

This is the greatest challenge which sex trafficking presents to law. Barry, KathleenThe Prostitution of Sexuality.

New York University Press. Short Essays on Migration and Gender. International Organization for Migration. Farr, KathrynSex Trafficking: The Global Market in Women and Children. Gilroy, PaulThe Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness.

Kempadoo, Kamala; Doezema, Jo eds. Rights, Resistance, and Redefinition. Lopes, AnaTrabalhadores do sexo uni-vos!

relationship between human trafficking and prostitution

Coloniality, Subaltern Knowledges, and Border Thinking. Ribeiro, Manuela et al. Even if the woman could call for help, she had no one to rescue her. The man told her that they needed money and that she would have to earn it.

People see a pimp as someone who obtains customers for a prostitute.

relationship between human trafficking and prostitution

The reality is that they use manipulation, threats, and violence to keep these women from leaving. They depend on the women they recruit into prostitution. These men use mental, emotional, and physical abuse to keep the women generating money. The men abandon women who are unable or unwilling to provide any more revenue.

Most prostitutes recognize their actions as illegal; however, a substantial number of them truly are victims. Pimps use various control methods to keep the women working the streets. Many of the prostitutes spoke of daily physical abuse, emotional dominance, and lies about caring. These men burned the women with curling irons, strangled, and punched them. They told the prostitutes that their families would be ashamed of them for being a hooker and that no one else would care for them.

Alone and removed from family and friends, these women have no money and depend on their pimps for food, shelter, and clothing.