Stannis and melisandre relationship problems

stannis and melisandre | Tumblr

stannis and melisandre relationship problems

But there's something else in Stannis's relationship with religion that and Melisandre of Asshai, who both frequently present opposing advice. Melisandre dismisses Cressen as old and fearful and challenges him to Melisandre at Stannis' council meeting at the Painted Table of Dragonstone. scattering the models onto the floor as he begins to have sex with her. In the books, Melisandre believes Stannis is Azor Ahai, who was the hero . TV show decided to highlight this connection in the outfits of both characters, . Melisandre's problem is that she has trouble interpreting the visions.

Stannis is the stoic, unable to feel romantic love or even basic sexual lust at all. House Baratheon's sigil is a clear symbol of masculinity, and the three Baratheon brothers seem to represent the different forms that masculinity can take.

Secondly there is the argument that Stannis must be asexual because he acts asexual— i. Rather, I think Stannis acts this way because he is personally insecure and shy around women, a combination that makes talking to females, indicating interest in them, and acknowledging his natural desire for sex to be something near impossible and embarrassing on his part.

In addition to being personally reserved and somewhat shy and awkward by nature, he is rather old fashioned, and especially socially awkward around women. Stannis is here, as in so many other things, the polar opposite of his brother. Robert handsome, friendly, can easily charm women and seduce them from an early age. Stannis, in contrast, has never been comfortable around them. The man was nothing to me Oh Robert loved him to be sure loved him like a brother how often did i hear that?

I was his brother not Ned but you never would have known it the way he treated me. Stannis feels resentful of Ned due to him getting credit for lifting the siege of Storms End when Stannis was inside holding out and starving living off of rats. He also took it as a slight that Ned was named hand of the king by Robert instead of him. Stannis and Melisandre Melisandre believes Stannis is the savior of her religion and is telling Stannis about how special he is.

stannis and melisandre relationship problems

I believe this does have an impact on him after all Stannis isnt used to people liking him at all and here is the woman constantly building him up. Stannis adopts the Lord Of Light somewhat he generally remains skeptical of religion but more on that later. Melisandre gains Stannis trusts by showing him magic she creates a shadow demon to kill Renly and Courtney Penrose to help Stannis although she doesnt do it anymore because it physically weakens Stannis.

It is very likely Stannis and Mel are having sex as Mel Comments that without Stannis around she has no use for a bed and the likelihood that the shadow babies were created through a sex.

Mel is kinda like the evil angel on Stannis shoulder whereas Davos is the good angel. Mel is ultimately able to convince Stannis to kill his bastard nephew Eldric Storm a child he hates due to him being created by Robert in Stannis bed on his wedding night for his kingsblood. Stannis and Shireen Despite his general cold nature Stannis is loving towards his daughter Shireen.

stannis and melisandre relationship problems

One might say it is the closest relationship he has with anyone. Stannis often defends Shireen and is outraged by Axel Florents secret plans to marry her to Tommen. He names Shireen as his heir in case he dies.

In the Theon Winds chapter Stannis says if he dies the soldiers should continue the war in order to put Shireen on the throne. Your Grace, if you are dead?

Justin Massey asked " You will avenge my death, and seat my daughter on the Iron Throne. Or die in the attempt. On the show of course Stannis encounters a snowstorm and burns Shireen however i cant see this happening in the books at all as Stannis is so far away from Shireen it just doesnt fit. As it turns out, this would not be the last time that he showed a diplomatic flexibility.

When Stannis first attempts to recruit the northern lords in his cause by sending out murders of ravens, he was almost uniformly rejected; the Karstarks duplicitously declared for Stannis, but a number of houses, such as the Mormonts, declared they would never swear fealty to anyone whose name was not Stark, and scores more never even responded. Homage might have been owed to Stannis by these houses and their lords, but his old approach of demanding their loyalty did not amend itself to receiving the pledges of fealty he desperately needed to win in the north.

Fortunately for Stannis, however, he still had Jon Snow. Lord Snow counseled Stannis to refrain from demanding fealty and instead offered a different idea for securing their loyalty: Your Grace will need to go to them yourself. The clans have not seen a king since Torrhen Stark bent his knee.

Your coming does them honor. He is no king of mine. Instead of begging or demanding, asking for help made it more possible for Stannis to win allies.

And win them he did, as we find northern clansmen attacking the ironborn at Deepwood Motte at his side. An important distinction to make here is that most of the northern houses and clans are fighting with Stannis not on behalf of his claim to the Iron Throne, but, rather, to rescue Arya Stark. The king has to be aware of this, and it has to grate on his pride considerably, but he nonetheless allows these men into his ranks and considers them some of his best soldiers in the north, giving them prestigious positions within his army.

Comparing Stannis to His Rivals: I had the cart before the horse. I was trying to win the throne to save the kingdom, when I should have been trying to save the kingdom to win the throne. How does his pragmatism and adaptability match up against other claimants to the throne, and, more importantly, does it make him a better contender for the crown? Renly Baratheon Stannis is most often compared and contrasted with his brother, Renly — not only by readers, but also by Stannis himself. Renly was easygoing; Stannis is not.

Renly made friends easily; Stannis declared that kings have no friends, only subjects and enemies. In the parlay between the two from A Clash of Kings, we see two very different views of kingship. Renly knew that Stannis had claim via royal inheritance, but he believed that the swords sworn to him gave him the right to be king.

This underlies his flexible morality — which just may be flexible to the point of seeming amoral — which is on display time and again in the series: In this, he was doubly usurping the throne, both from Joffrey and from his brother.

stannis and melisandre relationship problems

Instead, he investigated whether Joffrey, Myrcella, and Tommen were, indeed, bastards. This is the key to understanding the difference between the two brothers: Renly would usurp the throne because he thought he would make a good king and nothing else. Stannis would not make a claim unless he had evidence that would support it. Though Stannis called him a traitor and rebel, he and Robb possessed some key similarities — but also one fundamental difference.

In this, Robb had the horse before the cart — he saved the soon-to-be kingdom first before gaining the crown. In defeating Mance Rayder and the wildlings at Castle Black and then campaigning against both the ironmen at Deepwood Motte and the Boltons and Freys at Winterfell, Stannis was demonstrating value in defending the realm, and thereby demonstrating his value as a king, as well.

However, Robb Stark actually shows himself to be much more morally inflexible than Stannis. When Robb bedded Jeyne Westerling, he refused to simply dishonor her and move on; he married her instead, and, thus, started the sequence of events that brought his reign to a crashing, horrifying conclusion.

And Stannis did flinch from the implication that he was guilty of murder, giving a particularly poor alibi when questioned by Davos. However, his betrayal of his marriage vows — as well as the consequence of this betrayal — did not turn him aside from pursuing his claim to the Iron Throne.

Iron Bends: The Surprising Flexibility of Stannis Baratheon | Wars and Politics of Ice and Fire

Daenerys Targaryen At the end of the War of the Five Kings, Stannis stood alone as the last living king of the original contenders. Despite this minor victory, however, George R. Martin seems to be setting the stage for a confrontation between Stannis and another figure that he almost certainly does not know is coming to Westeros: The last Targaryen has been openly stating that the Iron Throne is hers by right.

Their contrasting views of justice provide even further illumination. While Stannis does believe that justice involves repaying injustice with punishment, he attempts to restore social order and execute justice without regard to his own personal feelings.

At the same time, Stannis rewarded Davos with a knighthood for this good act.

stannis and melisandre

In this, Stannis shows a fairness and flexibility in rewarding and punishing good and bad acts respectively. She shows a flexibility in dealing with the Meereenese and attempts peace through a distasteful marriage. She comes to believe that dragons plant no trees, and she is taking this to mean that only fire and blood are her recourses — a mentality that will no doubt be brought to Westeros.

I doubt that her sudden reappearance will present another hard choosing for him; he will continue to press his claim by demonstrating actual value and simultaneously oppose the queen who will bring only vengeance, fire, and blood to Westeros instead of restoring justice. Here, we find Stannis and his army waiting for the Boltons and Freys to attack him near Winterfell. Freezing and near-starvation, they remained loyal to Stannis and ready to die for the would-be southron king in the battle to come — with the sole exception of the Karstarks, of course, whose disloyalty was quickly discovered and dealt with.

Is this the work of a king who would break before bending? Stannis Baratheon is and always will be a controversial character in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire and the fandom. He is the recipient of legitimate criticism over many of his actions, but the interpretation of him as hard, unyielding, and inflexible is unjust.

Donal Noye died fighting against the wildling invasion before Stannis could arrive at the Wall, but I wonder how he would have viewed the king had he survived.

Would he still hold to the view that Stannis was iron? Or would he have a more positive appraisal? I think the latter.