Dakin and irwin relationship problems

The History Boys Essay - Drinks With Dakin

dakin and irwin relationship problems

erotic and non-erotic dominance in his and Irwin's relationship. name written by Alan Bennett, presents a character who challenges this requirement for scene, Dakin and Irwin discuss the dynamics of dominance and submission through a. Dakin is cruel- he flirts with Posner in the French lesson. Dakin and Irwin's relationship- I believe this is a key dramatic plot in the play of. He challenges them to bring an unusual perspective, to make the essays Posner knows he has a crush on Dakin, and even Dakin knows this too. is to Posner, mostly out of deference to the teacher-student relationship.

The show has prominent gay themes.

  • What bothers me about The History Boys

Irwin and Posner are explicitly gay, and Hector is probably gay he does fondle attractive boy's crotches. While yes, this is an old fashioned pederasty and certainly a suitable pursuit for Hector, enamored as he is with the history of culturein today's society we would probably consider this homosexuality.

Irwin and Hector both suppress their homosexuality. Irwin is presented as a stammering failure and ultimately sell out, and Hector is a doddering fool. Even Posner is encouraged to suppress, he's told "he'll get over it" despite his insistence that he doesn't want to get over it.

dakin and irwin relationship problems

All the other characters are presumably straight. They go on at length about sexual pursuits. Dakken enjoys a more fluid sexuality but he's obviously the sort of person willing to do most anything to achieve a goal.


He is, presumably, straight, and a winner, in the end. Irwin, who has already become a troubled, repressed individual, is confined to a wheel chair. Hector finds that his life long belief in education has apparently failed him and dies. Posner becomes old and lonely and can never figure out what went wrong. Now first off, this is a complaint about the dramatic structure of the play.

I thought the sudden tragic ending was a little out of left field. Also, the play itself is meant to be a tribute to Hector's character. BUT we're told that his lessons only live on in Posner's heart, and as consequence Posner lives a life unfulfilled in any way.

I feel like this is really old school homophobia. The eccentric gay characters are punished with loneliness and failure. With Irwin and Hector, it is explicitly because they are gay. But the open, impulsive, and headstrong Posner, who in no way ever displays any qualities of a person who will grow up and become that sort of person, is doomed to a life of loneliness.

We even get direct evidence of Posner's ambitions late in life. The other straight characters are certainly not doomed to such sad fates.

dakin and irwin relationship problems

Dakken may flirt with homosexuality but he isn't a homosexual. I can't help but feel the inevitable conclusion that it's because Posner's gay. I felt really offended by that. I thought that by the year we were over this sort of thinking, you know?

I'd like to hear other people's thoughts on this.

The History Boys Official Trailer!

He finds truth in the fiction stories of the great masters. But, he also doesn't want the reverence to literature to overwhelm the students with too great a level of respect. So, he has the students singing songs from musicals and watching classic movies, to make those stories, mass-appealing as they may be, as relevant as the classics. Irwin, by contrast, is the pragmatist. He sees admission as a game. While his students are technically proficient--they know their history backwards and forwards, their essays are fact-filled and parrot back the books they've read.

He challenges them to bring an unusual perspective, to make the essays interesting. The history boys seem keen on this, even as Hector bristles at the notion of history as game.

Lintott provides the female voice of reason, counterbalancing the foibles of Hector who, despite his love of teaching, can't seem to abandon his infatuation for his students, with one notable exception.

dakin and irwin relationship problems

If the movie uses Dakin as the ultra-hip guy who sleeps with secretaries and seems more than plenty bi-curious, it is Posner, the gay Jewish geek, who is the moral center of the film. Posner knows he has a crush on Dakin, and even Dakin knows this too. Dakin's a bit too cool to get involved, and he feels Posner is a bit too young.

dakin and irwin relationship problems

There are perhaps three key scenes in the film. First, Posner has a discussion with Irwin and says that he is homosexual and that he has a crush on Dakin and he knows it can't be returned. In a way, this confession is about Posner, but it is also about Irwin. Irwin wants to sympathize, but he's afraid to reveal who he truly is to Posner, mostly out of deference to the teacher-student relationship. Posner has another discussion with Hector about a story he's read and Hector tells him that novels are compelling because sometimes you have a feeling, one you think is completely personal, and realize that such a feeling is there in written word by a man you've never met, and perhaps by someone long since dead.

Another key scene is Irwin and Hector talking in the hallway shortly after Hector has been told he's being let go because of his indiscretions. Lintott seems to feel that those indiscretions, as poor judgment as they may be, are perhaps not as severe as they could be, that as a teacher that cares about what he teaches, his contributions to a student's development more than offsets bad behavior.

Hector understands that Irwin himself is attracted to the boys and even as the boys think of Irwin as cooler, he advises Irwin to restrain himself, in particular, in his infatuation with Dakin.

To up the ante, Dakin wants to fool around with Irwin, especially after he has found out like many of his classmates that he's going to a top-notch college. It's his way of saying thanks.

dakin and irwin relationship problems

Irwin is uncomfortable at the advances, and eventually gives in to the idea of meeting Dakin. I'll quickly go over the other guys.

School of thought

Akhtar is an Indian Muslim. His character is not fleshed out that much and his inclusion probably says as much about modern British society's diversity than anything else. James Corden plays portly Timms, but is also a character that isn't that well-developed. He's there as the token big guy. Apparently, the actor has gone on to be in a successful British sitcom.

Character Study on Irwin from the History Boys by Danielle Noon on Prezi

Russell Tovey plays Rudge, the athlete. In a way, his view is the most honest. He doesn't care for book learning at all, despite being in a prep school. He plays the game somewhat, but thinks it's a waste of time. He dislikes the guile needed, and just wants to play sports. Andrew Knott plays Lockwood, who is not given much of a personality, and is there, one imagines, to be good looking.

One other character is the token African Brit, and like Akhtar, doesn't have that much of a personality. Jamie Parker plays Scripps. He's the Catholic, and is considered a bit of a cipher by best friend, Dakin, who wonders what Scripps does with all this religion.